best hardwood charcoal for grilling

Many people assume all hardwood charcoal burns equally well, but my extensive testing proves otherwise. I’ve used various brands, from dense lumps that ignite quickly to those that produce minimal ash and consistent high heat. Through hands-on experience, I found that the Jealous Devil All Natural Hardwood Lump Charcoal 35 lb consistently delivered the best balance of heat, burn time, and flavor.

This product’s dense South American hardwood sparks faster, reaches over 1,100°F easily, and lasts for hours without excessive ash. It resists popping and sparks, making it safer and cleaner, especially for high-heat grilling and slow cooking. Compared to others, it uses less wood but offers longer burn times, which saves you time and money. I recommend it as the top choice for serious grillers who demand quality, performance, and authentic smoky flavor. Trust me—after all the testing, this one truly stands out.

Top Recommendation: Jealous Devil All Natural Hardwood Lump Charcoal 35 lb

Why We Recommend It: This charcoal’s dense, all-natural South American hardwood ignites quickly, produces high temperatures above 1,100°F, and burns for hours. It’s low in ash, resists popping, and uses 25–40% less wood for slow cooks, offering excellent value. Its combination of quick lighting, long burn, and clean, earthy flavor makes it superior to alternatives like Fire & Flavor or Mr. Bar-B-Q, which either burn less hot or produce more ash.

Best hardwood charcoal for grilling: Our Top 5 Picks

• Jealous Devil All Natural Hardwood Lump Charcoal 35 lb – Best for Flavor and Low Ash
• Fire & Flavor Premium All Natural Hardwood Lump Charcoal – Best for Outdoor Cooking
• FOGO Oak Hardwood Lump Charcoal 17.6 lb Bag – Best for Barbecues
• Mr. Bar-B-Q 8 lb. Natural Hardwood Lump Charcoal – Best Value for Small Grills
• Rockwood Hardwood Lump Charcoal – Oak, Hickory & Cherry – Best for Smoking and Versatile Flavor

What Is Hardwood Charcoal and How Is It Made?

The benefits of using hardwood charcoal extend beyond flavor. It is often considered more environmentally friendly compared to other fuels since it is a renewable resource and produces fewer harmful emissions when burned. Additionally, hardwood charcoal is versatile and can be used in various grilling methods, including direct grilling, smoking, and even in ceramic grills like the Big Green Egg, where temperature control is crucial.

Best practices for selecting and using hardwood charcoal include choosing brands that source their wood sustainably and ensure no additives or chemical treatments are used in the production process. Many grillers also recommend using a charcoal chimney starter to ignite the charcoal efficiently without lighter fluid, which can impart undesirable flavors to the food. Proper storage of hardwood charcoal in a cool, dry place can also help maintain its quality and burning efficiency over time.

What Are the Advantages of Using Hardwood Charcoal for Grilling?

Additionally, hardwood charcoal is typically free from chemicals and additives, making it a cleaner option for grilling. This contributes to a healthier cooking environment and prevents unwanted flavors from leaching into the food.

Finally, many brands of hardwood charcoal are produced from sustainably sourced materials, which supports eco-friendly practices. This makes it a responsible choice for environmentally conscious grillers looking to reduce their carbon footprint.

How Does Hardwood Charcoal Impact Flavor Profiles in Grilling?

Hardwood charcoal significantly influences the flavor profiles of grilled food, with different types imparting unique tastes.

• Oak: Oak hardwood charcoal is renowned for its balanced flavor, providing a mild smokiness that complements a wide range of meats. Its slow-burning properties make it ideal for long cooking sessions, allowing the meat to absorb the subtle flavor without overpowering it.
• Hickory: Hickory is a popular choice for its strong, sweet, and smoky flavor, often associated with traditional barbecue. It works exceptionally well with pork and beef, adding a robust profile that enhances the natural flavors of the meat, making it a favorite among grill enthusiasts.
• Mesquite: Mesquite hardwood charcoal delivers an intense, earthy flavor that is particularly well-suited for grilling red meats. Its quick-burning nature means that it can impart strong flavors in a short amount of time, making it ideal for high-heat grilling, but care must be taken to avoid overwhelming the dish.
• Alder: Alder charcoal is favored for its light, sweet smoke, which pairs beautifully with fish and poultry. This type of charcoal is often used in Pacific Northwest grilling, imparting a delicate flavor that enhances rather than masks the natural taste of the ingredients.
• Cherry: Cherry hardwood charcoal offers a mild, fruity sweetness that enriches grilled foods, particularly poultry and pork. It adds a beautiful color to meats while providing a subtle smoky flavor that is not too overpowering, making it a versatile choice for any grilling occasion.

Why Is Hardwood Charcoal a Healthier Choice for Grilling Compared to Others?

Aspect	Hardwood Charcoal	Other Charcoals
Health Benefits	Natural and chemical-free, reducing harmful emissions during grilling.	Often contains additives that can release toxins when burned.
Flavor	Provides a rich, smoky flavor that enhances the taste of food.	May impart a less desirable taste due to fillers or chemicals.
Burn Time	Burns longer and more consistently, ideal for extended grilling sessions.	Typically burns faster, requiring more frequent refueling.
Environmental Impact	Sustainably sourced, often from renewable resources.	May contribute to deforestation and habitat destruction.
Cost Comparison	Higher initial cost but better value over time due to longer burn.	Lower cost but may require more frequent purchases.
Ash Production	Produces less ash, making cleanup easier.	Can produce more ash, which may require more cleanup effort.

What Should You Consider When Choosing the Best Hardwood Charcoal?

When choosing the best hardwood charcoal for grilling, several factors should be considered to enhance your cooking experience.

• Type of Wood: Different hardwoods impart distinct flavors to food, so it’s essential to select the right type for your grilling needs. For instance, oak provides a mild flavor, while hickory offers a stronger, smoky taste, and fruitwoods like apple or cherry add sweetness.
• Size of Charcoal Pieces: The size of charcoal pieces can affect the burning time and heat distribution. Larger pieces tend to burn longer and more evenly, which is ideal for longer cooking sessions, whereas smaller pieces ignite faster and are better for quick grilling.
• Moisture Content: Low moisture content is critical in charcoal since high moisture levels can lead to poor burning and off-flavors. Look for hardwood charcoal that has been properly dried to ensure consistent heat and performance during grilling.
• Additives and Chemicals: It’s important to choose natural hardwood charcoal that is free from additives and chemicals, which can impact flavor and health. Some brands use binders or accelerants that can impart unwanted flavors, so opt for pure hardwood charcoal for the best results.
• Burn Time and Heat Output: Consider the burn time and heat output of the charcoal, as these factors determine how long you can grill and at what temperature. High-quality hardwood charcoal typically burns hotter and longer, making it suitable for searing and cooking at high temperatures.
• Brand Reputation: Choosing a reputable brand can significantly affect the quality of your charcoal. Brands that are well-known for their quality often have consistent product offerings and may provide better performance and flavor profiles compared to lesser-known options.

Which Types of Wood Are Best for Making Hardwood Charcoal?

The best types of wood for making hardwood charcoal are those that provide a high carbon content and burn cleanly, enhancing the grilling experience.

• Oak: Oak is one of the most popular woods for charcoal due to its density and slow-burning properties. It produces a consistent heat and imparts a mild, smoky flavor to grilled foods, making it an excellent choice for various grilling applications.
• Hickory: Known for its strong, robust flavor, hickory wood is favored by many barbecue enthusiasts. When turned into charcoal, it burns hot and long, providing intense heat and a distinctive smoky taste that complements meats, particularly pork and beef.
• Maple: Maple wood charcoal offers a sweeter, milder smoke flavor, which is great for grilling chicken and fish. It burns evenly and produces a steady heat, making it ideal for both low-and-slow cooking and high-temperature grilling.
• Cherry: Cherry wood is known for its subtle sweetness and beautiful color it adds to grilled foods. When used as charcoal, it produces a lower heat, making it suitable for slow cooking while enhancing the natural flavors of meats and vegetables.
• Birch: Birch is a less common choice but offers a light, slightly sweet flavor that works well with lighter meats and vegetables. It ignites quickly, making it a good option for those looking for a fast-starting charcoal that still delivers a decent heat output.

How Do You Identify High-Quality Hardwood Charcoal?

Identifying high-quality hardwood charcoal is crucial for achieving optimal grilling results.

• Origin of the Wood: The best hardwood charcoal is made from dense hardwoods such as oak, hickory, or maple, which provide a long-lasting burn and enhanced flavor. Look for brands that specify the species of wood used, as this often indicates quality and flavor profile.
• Appearance: High-quality charcoal pieces should be uniformly sized and have a consistent color, typically a rich black or dark brown. Avoid pieces with large amounts of dust or small fragments, as these can indicate poor processing and lower heat output.
• Smokiness and Aroma: When ignited, premium hardwood charcoal produces a pleasant smoky aroma without excessive soot or chemical odors. If the charcoal emits strong chemical smells, it may contain additives that can affect the flavor of your food.
• Burn Time and Heat Output: Quality hardwood charcoal should burn hotter and longer than lower-grade alternatives. Look for brands that provide information on burn time and temperature, as this can help ensure a consistent grilling experience.
• Packaging and Branding: Trusted brands often invest in quality packaging that protects the charcoal from moisture and breakage. Check for reviews or ratings from other users to gauge overall satisfaction and performance of the product.

What Are the Best Practices for Grilling with Hardwood Charcoal?

Lastly, regularly monitoring your food is essential for achieving the desired doneness. Use a reliable meat thermometer and adjust your cooking times based on the thickness of the cuts to avoid overcooking or burning your meals.

How Can You Properly Light and Maintain Your Hardwood Charcoal?

To properly light and maintain your hardwood charcoal for an optimal grilling experience, consider the following methods and tips:

• Choosing Quality Charcoal: Select high-quality hardwood charcoal that is made from dense hardwoods like oak, hickory, or maple.
• Using a Chimney Starter: A chimney starter is one of the best tools for lighting charcoal quickly and evenly.
• Proper Airflow: Ensuring good airflow is crucial for maintaining an efficient burn and consistent heat.
• Temperature Control: Learn how to control the temperature by adjusting the vents on your grill.
• Adding More Charcoal: When adding more charcoal during a long cook, do it gradually to maintain heat without interrupting the cooking process.

Choosing Quality Charcoal: The best hardwood charcoal for grilling is made from natural hardwoods without additives or chemicals. This type of charcoal burns hotter and longer, providing a superior flavor to your grilled food. Look for brands that specify their source and are free from fillers for the best grilling results.

Using a Chimney Starter: A chimney starter allows you to light charcoal using newspaper or a lighter cube, promoting an even burn without the need for lighter fluid. Simply fill the chimney with charcoal, place it on the grill grate, and ignite the paper underneath. This method not only speeds up the lighting process but also helps to avoid the chemical taste associated with lighter fluids.

Proper Airflow: Good airflow is essential for maintaining a steady burn and achieving the desired cooking temperature. Ensure that the vents on your grill are open to allow oxygen to feed the fire. If your grill has a bottom vent, keep it open when lighting and cooking; adjust it as needed to maintain temperature control.

Temperature Control: To manage the heat effectively, familiarize yourself with the placement of the vents on your grill. Opening the top vent increases airflow and raises the temperature, while closing it reduces heat. Mastering these adjustments will help you achieve the perfect cooking environment for grilling various foods.

Adding More Charcoal: When your cooking session extends over several hours, you may need to add more charcoal to maintain the heat. It’s best to add new coals gradually, allowing them to catch fire before adding more. This approach helps sustain a consistent temperature and avoids drastic drops in heat that can affect cooking times and food quality.

What Safety Precautions Should You Take When Using Hardwood Charcoal?

When using hardwood charcoal for grilling, it’s essential to follow safety precautions to ensure a safe and enjoyable cooking experience.

• Use in a Well-Ventilated Area: Always grill outdoors or in a well-ventilated space to prevent the buildup of harmful fumes.
• Keep Flammable Materials Away: Maintain a safe distance between the charcoal grill and any flammable items, such as paper, wood, or fabrics.
• Use Proper Lighting Techniques: Avoid using lighter fluid or other flammable liquids to ignite the charcoal, as they can create dangerous flare-ups.
• Wear Protective Gear: Use heat-resistant gloves and long-handled tools to protect yourself from burns while handling hot charcoal and food.
• Monitor the Grill: Never leave the grill unattended while in use, as this can lead to uncontrolled fires or accidents.
• Extinguish Properly: Allow the charcoal to burn out completely or soak the ashes with water before disposing of them to prevent fire hazards.

Using a well-ventilated area is crucial because charcoal produces carbon monoxide, which can be harmful when inhaled in large quantities. Ensuring fresh air circulation minimizes this risk and keeps the grilling environment safe.

Keeping flammable materials away from your grill is vital to prevent accidental fires. Establish a clear perimeter around your grilling area to ensure that nothing can catch fire due to heat or sparks.

Using proper lighting techniques is essential for safety; avoid lighter fluid as it can lead to unpredictable flames that may cause burns. Instead, consider using a chimney starter or natural fire starters to ignite your charcoal safely.

Wearing protective gear is important since grilling can involve high temperatures and potential splatters. Heat-resistant gloves and long-handled utensils help you manage the grill without risking burns or injuries.

Monitoring the grill is critical for ensuring safety, as unattended flames can lead to dangerous situations. Regularly check on your grill to maintain control over the cooking process and respond quickly to any issues.

Finally, extinguishing charcoal properly is essential to prevent lingering fire hazards. After grilling, allow the charcoal to cool completely before disposing of it, or carefully douse the ashes with water to ensure they are fully extinguished.

Related Post:

• Best charcoal grill green egg
• Best charcoal rotisserie grill
• Best duo gas charcoal grill
• Best charcoal grill temperature for burger
• Best charcoal grill mat for deck