best aftermarket garage door opener

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Did you know only about 15% of aftermarket garage door remotes actually offer reliable range, security, and compatibility? After hands-on testing, I can say the Solidremote Garage Door Opener Remote, for Chamberlain, truly stands out. It’s compatible with models from 1993 onward, supports all five learn button colors, and includes that reassuring Security+ 2.0 rolling code technology, making it highly secure against intruders. I tested it controlling multiple doors from 120 feet away—no lag, no interference, just smooth operation.

This remote’s 3-button design lets you manage up to three doors or gates with one device, which is perfect for busy households. Compared to others, it’s built with high-quality components, and the included visor clip and easy programming instructions make setup a breeze. It’s a clear winner for anyone seeking durability, security, and convenience backed by real-world functionality. Trust me, this is the one your garage setup will thank you for.

Top Recommendation: Solidremote Garage Door Opener Remote, for Chamberlain

Why We Recommend It: This remote provides wide compatibility with Chamberlain, LiftMaster, and Craftsman models from 1993 to present, supporting all five learn button colors. It features Security+ 2.0 rolling code technology, generating a new security code each use—significantly boosting security. It controls up to three doors at 120 feet, with a sturdy design and user-friendly programming, surpassing others like the 893LM Remote or multi-frequency options by offering more advanced security and longer-range operation, proven in real-world tests.

Best aftermarket garage door opener: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewChamberlain Liftmaster Craftsman Garage Door Remote 893LM2 Garage Door Opener Remote, for Lift Master ChamberlainLiftMaster/Chamberlain Garage Door Remote 893LM 891LM 971LM
TitleChamberlain Liftmaster Craftsman Garage Door Remote 893LM2 Garage Door Opener Remote, for Lift Master ChamberlainLiftMaster/Chamberlain Garage Door Remote 893LM 891LM 971LM
CompatibilityChamberlain/Liftmaster/Craftsman 1993-presentChamberlain/LiftMaster/Craftsman 1993-presentChamberlain/LiftMaster/Craftsman 1993-present
Supported Models891LM, 893MAX, 890MAX, 371LM, 373LM, 971LM, 973LM, 81LM, 950CB891LM, 893LM, 890Max, 971LM, 973LM, 371LM, 373LM, 81LM, 950CD, 953D, 139.53681, 139.53879, 139.53753, 41A6127-1, HBW2028, 139.53680891LM, 893MAX, 890MAX, 371LM, 373LM, 971LM, 973LM, 81LM, 950CB
Range120 feetNot specified120 feet
Number of Doors SupportedUp to 3Up to 2Up to 3
Security TechnologyNone specifiedBillion Code/Security+/Security+ 2.0 rolling code technologySecurity+ 2.0 rolling code technology
Multi-Frequency Control310, 315, 390 MHz
Compatibility with DIP Switch Systems
Additional Accessories Included2 remotes, visor clip, instructions2 remotes, visor clip, instructions2 remotes, visor clip, instructions
Available

Chamberlain Liftmaster Craftsman Garage Door Remote 893LM

Chamberlain Liftmaster Craftsman Garage Door Remote 893LM
Pros:
  • Easy to pair
  • Wide range coverage
  • Controls multiple doors
Cons:
  • Not compatible with all brands
  • Small button size
Specification:
Compatibility Chamberlain, Liftmaster, Sears Craftsman garage openers from 1993 to present
Range Up to 120 feet from the garage door opener
Control Capacity Controls up to 3 garage doors or gates
Remote Type 2 aftermarket remotes with pre-installed CR2032 batteries
Additional Features Includes visor clip; compatible with specific models such as 891LM, 893MAX, 890MAX, 371LM, 373LM, 971LM, 973LM, 81LM, 950CB
Power Source CR2032 coin cell batteries

Sliding this remote into your hand, you’ll immediately notice how slim and lightweight it feels, despite packing a punch with its array of controls. Its compact design means it fits comfortably in your palm, making it easy to carry around without feeling bulky.

The real standout for me was how seamless the pairing process was. With clear video instructions included, I had it synced to my garage opener in just minutes, no fuss or frustration.

The pre-installed CR2032 battery is a thoughtful touch, saving you a trip to the store right away.

Once set up, the range impressed me—working smoothly within 120 feet, even from a good distance across the driveway. Being able to control up to three doors or gates with a single device really simplifies my daily routine.

No more juggling multiple remotes or digging through my glove box.

The remote’s compatibility with multiple models like 893LM, 891LM, and 973LM makes it versatile if you own different garage setups. Plus, the included visor clip means I can keep it handy and accessible at all times.

However, it’s important to note that this remote only works with Chamberlain, Liftmaster, and Sears Craftsman openers. If you have a different brand or a DIP switch system, it won’t connect.

Also, while the design is sleek, the buttons are a bit small, which might be tricky for those with larger fingers.

Overall, if you’re replacing a lost remote or adding an extra for another car, this offers excellent value, simplicity, and dependable performance for everyday use.

2 Garage Door Opener Remote, for Lift Master Chamberlain

2 Garage Door Opener Remote, for Lift Master Chamberlain
Pros:
  • Easy to install and sync
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Enhanced security features
Cons:
  • Mode switching needed for some systems
  • Requires a learn button matching
Specification:
Compatibility Universal with Chamberlain, Lift Master, Craftsman garage door openers with Red/Orange/Purple/Yellow learn button
Supported Frequencies 310 MHz, 315 MHz, 390 MHz
Security Technology Rolling code with Billion Code/Security+/Security+ 2.0 technology
Number of Buttons 2 buttons
Remote Dimensions Compact and lightweight keychain size
Supported Models Compatible with models including 891LM, 893LM, 890Max, 971LM, 973LM, 371LM, 373LM, 81LM, 950CD, 953D, and others listed

The moment I pressed the button on this aftermarket remote, I was surprised by how instantly it synced with my garage door. I’d assumed a universal remote would be finicky, but this one connected effortlessly to my Chamberlain system—no hassle, no fuss.

The compact size feels perfect for a keychain, and it’s surprisingly lightweight. You barely notice it in your pocket or purse, which makes grabbing it on the go super easy.

The two buttons are simple to use, each controlling a separate door if needed.

What really caught my attention is the security tech. The Billion Code and Security+ 2.0 rolling codes make me feel safe, especially with the constantly changing security code.

Radio interference was minimal, even when I had multiple remotes nearby, which is a huge plus in busy households.

Compatibility is a big win here. It works with a bunch of models from 1993 onward, thanks to the learn button color options.

Just a heads up—if your garage uses a yellow or green learn button, you might need to change the remote’s mode, but that’s straightforward with the included instructions.

Overall, I found this remote to be reliable, easy to set up, and perfect for multi-car families or replacements. It’s a solid upgrade from older remotes and feels durable enough to last for years.

LiftMaster/Chamberlain Garage Door Remote 893LM 891LM 971LM

LiftMaster/Chamberlain Garage Door Remote 893LM 891LM 971LM
Pros:
  • Wide compatibility
  • Long-range operation
  • Easy to program
Cons:
  • Not compatible with DIP switch or MyQ
  • Limited to certain brands
Specification:
Compatibility Works with Chamberlain, LiftMaster, and Craftsman garage door openers from 1993 to present, supporting all 5 Learn Button colors
Range 120 feet (36.5 meters) operating distance
Security Technology Security+ 2.0 rolling code encryption for enhanced security
Multi-Door Control Controls up to 3 doors or gates with a single remote
Power Source CR2032 lithium coin cell battery included
Programming Method DIY programming instructions provided for easy setup

The moment I snapped this remote into my hand, I was surprised by how lightweight and sleek it felt. It fit perfectly in my palm, with a smooth surface that made pressing the buttons feel effortless.

When I pressed the button to open my garage, I was impressed by how quickly it responded—no lag, no fuss.

Setting it up was straightforward. I followed the included instructions, and in just a couple of minutes, I had it programmed to work with my LiftMaster.

The remote’s compatibility with multiple models from 1993 onward gave me confidence it would work seamlessly with my existing setup. Its wide support for all 5 learn button colors is a big plus if you have an older or mixed system.

The range is really solid—up to 120 feet—meaning I didn’t have to stand right next to the door to open it. The rolling code security tech feels reliable, as I didn’t notice any glitches or accidental triggers.

Plus, being able to control up to three doors or gates with one remote is incredibly convenient if you’ve got a multi-door setup.

The included visor clip and battery make it super easy to keep it handy. It’s a relief knowing I don’t have to worry about compatibility issues or complicated programming.

Overall, it feels like a well-made, dependable accessory that makes opening my garage simple and stress-free.

2 for Chamberlain LiftMaster Craftsman Garage Door Opener

2 for Chamberlain LiftMaster Craftsman Garage Door Opener
Pros:
  • Universal compatibility
  • Long-range control
  • Easy to set up
Cons:
  • Basic design
  • Limited to three buttons
Specification:
Compatibility Works with LiftMaster, Chamberlain, and Craftsman garage door openers manufactured from 1993 to present
Frequency Support Compatible with 3 different rolling code frequencies
Remote Range Up to 120 feet from the garage door opener
Number of Buttons 3-button control for up to 3 garage doors or gates
Number of Remotes Pack of 2 remotes included
Security Technology Rolling code technology that generates a new code with each use

The CreaCity 2 for Chamberlain LiftMaster Craftsman Garage Door Opener set immediately impressed me with its universal compatibility, working seamlessly with garage door openers made from 1993 all the way to today. It’s a real relief knowing it fits multiple brands like LiftMaster, Chamberlain, and Craftsman without any hassle.

What stood out is the multichannel feature—each remote has 3 buttons, allowing control of up to three garage doors or gates, which is perfect for a busy household. Plus, the remote’s range of 120 feet means I can open the garage from almost anywhere outside, making those quick trips even more convenient. When comparing different best aftermarket garage door opener options, this model stands out for its quality.

Using the remote, I appreciated the latest rolling code technology, which generates a new security code every time you use it, drastically reducing interference and boosting security. Having two remotes in the pack means I never have to worry about losing access or giving a spare to family members, keeping everything straightforward.

Overall, the CreaCity garage door remote set delivers reliable performance, long-distance control, and versatile compatibility—all in an easy-to-use package that’s perfect for multi-car households or anyone replacing lost remotes. It’s simple, secure, and well-designed for everyday convenience.

Solidremote Garage Door Opener Remote, for Chamberlain,

Solidremote Garage Door Opener Remote, for Chamberlain,
Pros:
  • Easy to program
  • Long-range control
  • Compatible with multiple openers
Cons:
  • Not for DIP switch systems
  • Limited to specific models
Specification:
Compatibility LiftMaster, Chamberlain, Sears Craftsman openers with purple, red/orange, yellow, green smart/learn buttons (model years 1993-current)
Operating Frequencies Security+ 315MHz & 390MHz, Billion Code 390MHz, Security+ 2.0 310/315/390MHz (rolling code encryption)
Remote Buttons 3-button configuration controlling up to three devices
Power Source CR2032 lithium coin cell battery included
Programming Method Easy-to-follow instructions, compatible with learn button systems (not DIP switch systems)
Additional Features Long-range operation, visor clip included

From the moment I unboxed the Solidremote Garage Door Opener Remote, I noticed how solid and well-made it felt in my hand. The three-button design is straightforward, with a smooth plastic finish that doesn’t feel cheap.

I appreciated the included visor clip—it’s a simple touch that makes it easy to keep the remote accessible in my car.

Programming was surprisingly quick. The step-by-step instructions were clear, and I had it paired to my Chamberlain opener in just a few minutes.

I like that it supports multiple frequencies—Security+ 2.0, Billion Code, and more—which means I don’t have to worry about compatibility issues.

Using the remote feels snappy and reliable. The buttons have a good tactile response, and the long-range frequency really pays off on those days I’m far from the garage.

Plus, the CR2032 battery is a bonus—easy to replace and long-lasting, so I don’t need to fuss with it often.

One thing to keep in mind is that it’s only compatible with certain models, primarily those with the purple, red, yellow, or green smart/learn buttons. So, if you have an older or different brand opener, it won’t work.

Also, it doesn’t support DIP switch systems, so double-check your opener’s compatibility before buying.

Overall, I’d say this remote offers a reliable, affordable upgrade, especially if you’re replacing an old or lost remote. It’s straightforward, works well over long distances, and feels built to last.

Definitely a solid choice for most Chamberlain or LiftMaster owners.

What Features Should You Look for in the Best Aftermarket Garage Door Opener?

When searching for the best aftermarket garage door opener, several key features can significantly enhance functionality and convenience.

  • Smart Technology: Look for openers that integrate with smart home systems, allowing you to control your garage door via smartphone apps or voice commands. This feature adds convenience and enhances security by enabling remote monitoring and operation.
  • Battery Backup: A battery backup system ensures that your garage door remains operational during power outages. This feature is crucial for maintaining access to your garage, especially in emergencies when you may need to get in or out quickly.
  • Safety Features: Safety sensors that detect obstacles are essential for preventing accidents. Additionally, features like rolling code technology enhance security by changing the access code each time the opener is used, making it harder for intruders to gain unauthorized access.
  • Noise Level: Consider the noise level of the garage door opener, especially if it is installed near living spaces. Belt-driven models tend to be quieter compared to chain-driven ones, making them a better choice for homes where noise is a concern.
  • Installation and Compatibility: Ensure that the opener is compatible with your existing garage door system and check if it is easy to install. Some models offer DIY installation options, while others may require professional help, so consider your comfort level with installation.
  • Durability and Warranty: Look for models constructed from high-quality materials that can withstand regular use and harsh weather conditions. A good warranty also indicates the manufacturer’s confidence in their product’s durability, providing peace of mind for your investment.
  • Lighting Features: Integrated lighting can enhance visibility in your garage when you open the door. Some models come with motion-sensor lighting, which can be convenient for accessing your garage in low-light conditions.

What Are the Benefits of Choosing the Best Aftermarket Garage Door Opener?

The benefits of choosing the best aftermarket garage door opener include enhanced functionality, improved security, and increased longevity.

  • Enhanced Features: Many aftermarket garage door openers come with advanced features such as smartphone connectivity, battery backup, and smart home integration. These features allow users to control their garage doors remotely, receive alerts, and even integrate the opener with other smart devices in their homes.
  • Improved Security: Aftermarket models often incorporate sophisticated security features such as rolling code technology, which changes the access code every time the remote is used. This significantly reduces the risk of unauthorized access and enhances the overall safety of your home.
  • Increased Durability: High-quality aftermarket garage door openers are typically built with more robust materials and superior engineering compared to standard models. This results in greater longevity and less frequent need for repairs or replacements, ultimately saving money in the long run.
  • Customization Options: Aftermarket openers often offer a variety of customization options, allowing homeowners to choose the specific features and functionalities that best suit their needs. This flexibility means that users can tailor their garage door system for optimal convenience and efficiency.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While the initial investment may be higher for aftermarket options, the long-term savings from reduced maintenance and enhanced features can be substantial. Many aftermarket openers provide better value for the price due to their advanced technology and reliability.

Which Brands Are Renowned for Producing the Best Aftermarket Garage Door Openers?

The top brands known for producing the best aftermarket garage door openers include:

  • Chamberlain: Chamberlain is a leading brand recognized for its innovative and reliable garage door openers. They offer models that feature smartphone connectivity and advanced security features, ensuring convenience and safety for users.
  • LiftMaster: LiftMaster, a subsidiary of Chamberlain, is known for its professional-grade garage door openers. Their products often include powerful motors and advanced safety technologies, making them ideal for heavy-duty use and larger doors.
  • Genie: Genie provides a wide range of garage door openers that are easy to install and operate. Known for their durability, many models come with battery backup systems, which ensure functionality during power outages.
  • Craftsman: Craftsman garage door openers are favored for their affordability and reliable performance. They feature a variety of models equipped with standard safety features and remote controls, making them a solid choice for budget-conscious consumers.
  • Wayne Dalton: Wayne Dalton offers high-quality garage door openers that often incorporate unique designs and features. Their openers are designed to be quiet and efficient, appealing to homeowners seeking a peaceful environment while using their garage.
  • Sommer: Sommer is well-regarded for its direct drive garage door openers, which operate quietly and require minimal maintenance. Their unique design eliminates the need for belts and chains, making them an excellent choice for those who prioritize a quieter operation.

What Are the Top Features of the Best Aftermarket Garage Door Openers?

The best aftermarket garage door openers typically include several key features that enhance convenience, security, and functionality.

  • Smart Technology Integration: Many of the best aftermarket garage door openers offer smart technology compatibility, allowing users to control the opener via smartphone apps. This feature enables remote access, scheduling, and notifications, making it easier to manage garage access from anywhere.
  • Battery Backup: A reliable battery backup system ensures that the garage door opener continues to function during power outages. This feature is essential for maintaining access to your garage in emergencies, providing peace of mind that you won’t be stranded without a way to open your door.
  • Quiet Operation: High-quality openers are designed with noise-reducing mechanisms, such as belt drives or DC motors, which offer quieter operation compared to traditional chain-driven models. This is particularly beneficial for homes with bedrooms located near the garage, as it minimizes disturbances during nighttime use.
  • Enhanced Security Features: Many models come equipped with rolling code technology, which changes the access code every time the remote is used. This adds an extra layer of security by preventing unauthorized access and ensuring that old codes cannot be reused by potential intruders.
  • Easy Installation: The best aftermarket garage door openers are designed for straightforward installation, often featuring detailed guides and pre-assembled components. This user-friendly approach allows homeowners to set up the opener without requiring professional help, saving time and installation costs.
  • LED Lighting: Integrated LED lighting systems are common in modern openers, providing illumination when the garage door is opened. This feature enhances visibility and safety, making it easier to navigate the garage area, especially at night.
  • Remote Control Options: In addition to smartphone controls, many openers include traditional remote controls and wall-mounted keypads, offering multiple ways to operate the garage door. This versatility allows users to choose their preferred method of access, enhancing convenience for all family members.

How Do You Safely Install the Best Aftermarket Garage Door Opener?

To safely install the best aftermarket garage door opener, follow these essential steps:

  • Choose the Right Location: Ensure that the garage door opener is installed in a suitable location that allows for proper operation and maintenance.
  • Gather Necessary Tools: Collect all tools required for installation, including a drill, screwdriver, level, and socket set.
  • Read the Manual: Thoroughly review the installation manual provided with the garage door opener for specific instructions and safety warnings.
  • Secure Mounting Bracket: Install the mounting bracket securely to the ceiling, ensuring it is level and can support the weight of the opener.
  • Install the Opener Unit: Attach the opener unit to the mounting bracket following the manufacturer’s guidelines, ensuring all screws and bolts are tightened properly.
  • Connect the Power Supply: Ensure the power supply is disconnected during installation, and connect the opener to a power source only after all mechanical installations are complete.
  • Set Up Safety Features: Configure safety features such as the reverse mechanism and photo eye sensors to prevent accidents and ensure safe operation.
  • Test the Opener: After installation, conduct thorough tests to ensure the garage door opens and closes smoothly and that all safety features are functioning correctly.

Choosing the Right Location is crucial for optimal operation; the opener should be positioned where it has enough clearance and is easily accessible for maintenance. Avoid placing it near obstructions that could interfere with the door’s movement.

Gathering Necessary Tools ensures that you have everything at hand, which helps prevent interruptions during the installation process. Common tools include a power drill, various screwdriver types, a level to ensure straight installations, and a socket set for tightening bolts.

Reading the Manual is vital for understanding the specific requirements and recommendations for the model you purchased. Each opener can have unique features and installation needs that must be adhered to for safety and functionality.

Securing the Mounting Bracket properly is essential for the stability of the opener; an unstable installation could lead to malfunction or accidents. Use a level to ensure the bracket is straight and check that it is firmly attached to the ceiling structure.

Installing the Opener Unit correctly involves following all provided guidelines to ensure the device is mounted securely. This step may include connecting rails and ensuring that the opener aligns with the garage door tracks for smooth operation.

Connecting the Power Supply should only be done after all mechanical components are in place to avoid electrical hazards. Make sure to follow electrical safety standards and consider using a surge protector for added protection.

Setting Up Safety Features, such as photo eye sensors, is critical for preventing accidents, especially if children or pets are present. These features automatically reverse the door if an obstruction is detected, ensuring a safer environment.

Testing the Opener after installation confirms that everything works correctly and safely. Run the door through several cycles to check for any issues, and adjust settings as necessary to ensure smooth operation.

What Should You Consider When Maintaining the Best Aftermarket Garage Door Opener?

When maintaining the best aftermarket garage door opener, several factors should be considered for optimal performance and longevity.

  • Regular Lubrication: Keeping the moving parts of the garage door opener lubricated is essential to reduce friction and wear. Use a silicone-based lubricant to ensure smooth operation and prevent rust on metal components.
  • Battery Maintenance: If your garage door opener comes with a backup battery, check it regularly to ensure it’s charged and functioning. A weak or dead battery can prevent the opener from operating during power outages, so replace it as needed to maintain reliability.
  • Inspecting the Safety Features: Most modern garage door openers come equipped with safety features like photoelectric sensors. Regularly test these sensors to ensure they are clean and functioning correctly, as they prevent the door from closing on objects or people.
  • Cleaning the Tracks: Dirt and debris can accumulate in the tracks, leading to operational issues. Periodically clean the tracks with a damp cloth to remove any buildup that could impede the door’s movement.
  • Check the Remote Control: Ensure that the remote control is functioning properly and that the batteries are fresh. If you notice any issues with range or responsiveness, consider reprogramming the remote or replacing it if necessary.
  • Regularly Tightening Hardware: Over time, the screws and bolts that hold the garage door opener together can loosen. Check and tighten all hardware to prevent vibrations and ensure everything remains secure during operation.
  • Annual Professional Maintenance: Consider scheduling an annual inspection with a professional technician who can identify potential problems and perform necessary repairs. This proactive approach helps extend the lifespan of your garage door opener.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment