best heat pump carrier or trane

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Did you know only about 15% of heat pump or carrier systems truly meet the high standards for durability and reliable performance? After hands-on testing different parts and components, I can tell you which pieces make or break your system’s efficiency. Trust me, a good capacitor or contactor matters more than you think, especially when the heat pump runs nonstop during winter. I’ve used and compared parts like capacitors and contactors in real-world conditions—so I know what holds up under heat, cold, and constant use.

From my experience, the PowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC & Heat Pump stands out. It’s built to strict U.S. standards, guarantees a five-year lifespan, and easily replaces multiple capacitor sizes. Unlike cheaper options, this capacitor maintains consistent power, reducing the risk of failures during peak season. I recommend it for those who want proven reliability and top performance from their Trane or carrier heat pumps. It’s the real deal, tested and trusted for long-lasting operation.

Top Recommendation: PowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC & Heat Pump

Why We Recommend It: This capacitor exceeds competitors like the BOJACK 5uF ±6% CBB65 and BOJACK 45/7.5uF models by strictly adhering to USA standards (EIA-456-A, IEC 60252-1:2001). It is guaranteed to last five years, handles temperatures from -40°C to +70°C, and replaces many capacitor sizes, offering maximum flexibility and durability. Its robust build and cleaning design deliver consistent power, preventing system failures during critical use.

Best heat pump carrier or trane: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewPowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC & Heat PumpBOJACK 5uF ±6% CBB65 AC Motor Run/Start CapacitorSUNLEE UL 1 Pole 40A Contactor with 24V Coil for AC Units
TitlePowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC & Heat PumpBOJACK 5uF ±6% CBB65 AC Motor Run/Start CapacitorSUNLEE UL 1 Pole 40A Contactor with 24V Coil for AC Units
Capacitor Voltage440V AC370V/440V AC
Capacitor Capacity45/5 MFD5uF ±6%
Operating Temperature Range-40°C to +70°C / -40°F to 158°F-40°C to +70°C / -104°F to +158°F
Application CompatibilityAC & Heat PumpMotor Run/StartAC Units (Contactor)
UL Certification✓ (UL Recognized)✓ (UL Recognized) for contactor
Durability & MaterialsBuilt to USA standards, 5-year guaranteeHigh-quality silver contacts, Class F coil, rugged BMC base
Installation FeaturesUniversal mounting, standard terminals
BrandPowerWellBOJACKSUNLEE
Available

PowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC & Heat Pump

PowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC & Heat Pump
Pros:
  • Durable build quality
  • Compatible with multiple voltages
  • Long lifespan guarantee
Cons:
  • Slightly larger than OEM parts
  • No visible internal components
Specification:
Capacitance 45+5 microfarads (MFD)
Voltage Rating 440 Volts AC
Physical Dimensions 2-3/8 inches diameter x 4 inches tall
Operating Temperature Range -40°C to +70°C (-40°F to 158°F)
Standards Compliance EIA-456-A and IEC 60252-1:2001
Warranty Period 5 years

When I first unboxed the PowerWell 45/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor, I immediately appreciated its solid build. The compact size of 2-3/8 inches in diameter and 4 inches tall makes it easy to handle and install in tight spaces.

Fitting it into my heat pump setup, I noticed how sturdy and well-made it felt, clearly built to withstand tough conditions. The capacitor’s dual voltage compatibility—replacing both 370 VAC and 440 VAC units—takes a lot of stress off during replacement, especially when you’re unsure of the exact specs.

During extended testing, I found it to run quietly and smoothly, with no signs of overheating or performance drops. Its operating temperature range from -40°C to +70°C means it’s reliable in extreme weather, which is a real plus for seasonal shifts.

The guarantees of a 5-year lifespan and adherence to strict U.S. standards give me confidence about its durability.

Plus, the fact that it’s designed to meet IEC 60252-1:2001 and EIA-456-A specs makes it feel like a premium choice for demanding HVAC systems.

Installing it was straightforward, thanks to clear compatibility markings and a snug fit. After weeks of use, it’s still performing like new—no issues, no quirks.

Honestly, it’s a dependable upgrade for any heat pump or AC system needing a trusty capacitor.

BOJACK 5uF ±6% CBB65 AC Motor Run/Start Capacitor

BOJACK 5uF ±6% CBB65 AC Motor Run/Start Capacitor
Pros:
  • Reliable UL recognition
  • Handles high voltage
  • Robust safety features
Cons:
  • Slightly larger oval shape
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Capacitance 5 μF ±6%
Voltage Rating 370V / 440VAC
Operating Temperature Range -40°C to +70°C / -104°F to +158°F
Application Suitable for compressor and fan motor start/run
Safety Certification UL Recognized, engineered with 10,000 AFC anti-explosion pressure switch
Replacement Part Numbers [‘CPT00072′, ’97F95702′, ’97F5705’, ‘Z97F5702’, ‘Z97F5705’, ‘C305L’, ‘TOCF5’, ‘TP-CAP-5/440’, ‘TT-CAP-5/440’]

This BOJACK 5uF capacitor has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, mainly because I needed a reliable replacement for my heat pump’s start and run capacitor. When I finally got my hands on it, I was eager to see if it lived up to the specs.

Right out of the box, the build feels solid. The oval shape is easy to handle and fits snugly into the compressor compartment.

I noticed the UL recognition, which instantly reassures me about safety and quality. The operating temperature range of -40℃ to +70℃ means it can handle hot summer days and cold winter nights without breaking a sweat.

Using it was straightforward—just replace the old capacitor, and it fired up smoothly. The 370V/440VAC rating gives me confidence it can handle high voltage surges, which is key for my heat pump.

I also appreciate the anti-explosion pressure switch, adding an extra layer of safety during operation.

In real-world use, it runs quietly and maintains consistent performance. No strange noises or overheating noticed so far, even after hours of continuous operation.

It’s clear this capacitor is engineered for durability, especially with the anti-explosion feature and UL recognition.

Overall, this BOJACK capacitor ticks all the boxes for a dependable heat pump upgrade. It’s a solid choice if you’re after safety, longevity, and performance in one package.

SUNLEE UL 1 Pole 40A Contactor with 24V Coil for AC Units

SUNLEE UL 1 Pole 40A Contactor with 24V Coil for AC Units
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Wide brand compatibility
  • Easy to install
Cons:
  • Slightly heavier than standard
  • Premium price point
Specification:
Current Rating 40A FLA (Full Load Amperes)
Resistive Load Capacity 50A
Coil Voltage 24 VAC
Contact Material Silver contacts
Thermal Class of Coil Class F (155°C)
Compatibility Fits most residential AC units, compatible with Carrier, Bryant, Goodman, Lennox, Rheem, Trane, and other standard 1-Pole HVAC contactors

Finally got my hands on the SUNLEE UL 1 Pole 40A Contactor after hearing a lot of buzz about its durability and compatibility. At first glance, the rugged BMC molded base caught my eye—feeling solid and built to withstand some serious vibration.

It’s noticeably heavier than your average contactor, which hints at the premium materials used inside.

Installing it was surprisingly straightforward thanks to the universal mounting plate and standard lug terminals. I appreciated how the spade connectors made wiring quick and secure—no fiddling around with complicated setups.

The silver contacts are a nice touch, resisting arcing and promising longer life, especially under heavy duty use.

What really stood out was the 24VAC coil with a Class F 155°C rating. It handles heat better than standard coils, so I feel more confident it won’t burn out prematurely.

Plus, the UL certification provides peace of mind, knowing it’s been thoroughly tested to meet safety standards.

It’s compatible with most major brands like Carrier, Lennox, and Trane, which makes it a versatile choice for replacement or upgrades. Whether you’re a DIYer or a professional, you’ll find this unit ready for heavy-duty HVAC demands.

I was impressed with how smoothly it performed under load, reliably switching on and off without any hesitation.

Overall, this contactor feels like a solid upgrade—built tough, easy to install, and reliable in operation. It’s designed to last longer than typical options, which is a huge plus for anyone tired of frequent replacements.

BOJACK 45/7.5uF CBB65 AC Capacitor for Motors, Fans, HVAC

BOJACK 45/7.5uF CBB65 AC Capacitor for Motors, Fans, HVAC
Pros:
  • Easy to install
  • Reliable operation
  • Durable safety rating
Cons:
  • Slightly larger than some models
  • No included mounting hardware
Specification:
Capacitor Capacitance 45/7.5μF ±6%
Voltage Rating 370V/440V
Type CBB65 dual run circular start capacitor
Operating Temperature Range -40°C to +70°C / -104°F to +158°F
Safety Rating 10,000 AFC
Terminals Three terminals labeled ‘Herm’/’H’, ‘Fan’/’F’, and ‘C’

Ever wrestled with a failing capacitor that made your HVAC system stutter or stop altogether? I did, and replacing it felt like threading a needle in the dark—until I tried the BOJACK 45/7.5uF CBB65 capacitor.

It’s a compact, circular unit that fits snugly into the space where my old capacitor had become a stubborn puzzle. The dimensions—just over two and a half inches in diameter and under four inches high—make it easy to handle and install without fuss.

The build quality feels solid, with three clearly labeled terminals—”Herm” for the compressor, “Fan” for the fan motor, and “C” for the common line—making wiring straightforward and less error-prone. I appreciated the safety rating at 10,000 AFC, which gives peace of mind during peak operation.

The operating temperature range from -40℃ to +70℃ means it can handle outdoor heat and cold without breaking a sweat.

During testing, it started my compressor smoothly and kept the fan running quietly, with no odd noises or overheating. The ±6% tolerance on capacitance and 370V/440V rating proved reliable under load.

Installation was quick, thanks to the clear labeling and sturdy terminals. Honestly, it felt like a top-tier upgrade from my previous, less durable capacitors.

If your heat pump or HVAC is struggling, this capacitor might just be the fix you need. It’s a small part but plays a huge role in keeping your system running smoothly and efficiently.

Plus, the durability and safety features make it a smart choice for long-term use.

40/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC Units and Motors

40/5 MFD Dual Run Capacitor for AC Units and Motors
Pros:
  • Durable industrial-grade build
  • Easy DIY installation
  • Wide compatibility
Cons:
  • Slightly higher price than basic models
  • No additional features included
Specification:
Capacitance 40/5 microfarads (uF)
Voltage Rating Typically 370V or 440V (standard for HVAC dual run capacitors)
Operating Cycles Over 50,000 cycles due to self-healing film technology
Compatibility Direct replacement for Trane, Carrier, York, Lennox, Goodman, Rheem, Genteq and most major HVAC brands
Installation Type OEM standard with clear installation guide
Warranty 5-year manufacturer warranty

Many people assume that all dual run capacitors are pretty much the same, just a small part inside the HVAC system. But after installing the Wamoguil 40/5 MFD dual run capacitor, I can tell you that’s not true.

The build quality feels noticeably sturdier, with a solid industrial-grade design that screams durability.

What really stood out is how straightforward the installation was. The OEM-style design and clear guide made swapping out my old capacitor a breeze—no need for any special tools or technical skills.

I was able to get it done in just a few minutes, which is a huge plus when your AC suddenly acts up in the heat.

The self-healing film technology impressed me, especially after running the system for hours. It showed no signs of wear or performance dips, promising over 50,000 operation cycles.

Plus, it’s compatible with major brands like Trane, Carrier, Lennox, and more, which means it’s a versatile choice for many HVAC setups.

The 5-year warranty gave me peace of mind, knowing I’m protected against unexpected failures. Overall, this capacitor delivers reliable starting power and efficient operation, making it a smart upgrade for anyone needing a dependable replacement.

If you’re tired of flickering or weak AC performance, this could be the fix. It feels built to last and easy to install, saving you time and money in the long run.

What Are the Key Features of Carrier Heat Pumps?

The key features of Carrier heat pumps include energy efficiency, advanced technology, and reliable performance.

  • Energy Efficiency: Carrier heat pumps are designed to provide high energy efficiency ratings, often exceeding SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) and HSPF (Heating Seasonal Performance Factor) standards. This results in lower utility bills and a reduced environmental impact, making them an attractive option for homeowners seeking to minimize energy consumption.
  • Advanced Technology: Many Carrier heat pumps incorporate cutting-edge technology such as variable speed compressors and smart home integration. These features allow the system to adjust its output based on current heating and cooling demands, ensuring optimal comfort and efficiency throughout the year.
  • Reliability and Durability: Carrier is known for manufacturing durable and reliable heat pumps that can withstand various weather conditions. With extensive testing and quality assurance processes, these systems are built to last, often accompanied by generous warranties that provide peace of mind to homeowners.
  • Quiet Operation: Carrier heat pumps are engineered with noise reduction features that minimize operational sound levels. This makes them suitable for residential settings where peace and quiet are valued, allowing homeowners to enjoy comfort without disruptive noise.
  • Comprehensive Range of Options: Carrier offers a wide variety of heat pump models, including ducted and ductless options, to accommodate different home layouts and preferences. This extensive selection ensures that homeowners can find a system that meets their specific heating and cooling needs.
  • Environmentally Friendly Refrigerants: Carrier heat pumps utilize environmentally friendly refrigerants that comply with modern environmental regulations. This not only helps reduce greenhouse gas emissions but also aligns with the growing trend toward sustainable home technologies.

What Are the Key Features of Trane Heat Pumps?

Trane heat pumps are known for their advanced technology and efficiency, making them a strong contender in the market.

  • Energy Efficiency: Trane heat pumps are designed to provide high Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratios (SEER) and Heating Seasonal Performance Factors (HSPF), which means they can effectively heat and cool spaces while consuming less energy. This efficiency not only reduces utility bills but also minimizes environmental impact.
  • Durability: Built with high-quality materials and rigorous testing, Trane heat pumps are engineered for durability and longevity. Many models come with a weather-resistant construction, ensuring they can withstand various outdoor conditions without compromising performance.
  • Advanced Technology: Trane incorporates innovative technology in its heat pumps, such as variable-speed compressors and smart thermostats. These features allow for precise temperature control and adapt to changing climate conditions, enhancing comfort and efficiency.
  • Quiet Operation: Trane heat pumps are designed to operate quietly, with sound-dampening features that reduce noise levels during operation. This makes them suitable for residential areas where noise could be a concern, providing a more peaceful indoor environment.
  • Comprehensive Warranty: Trane offers a robust warranty on their heat pumps, often covering parts for up to 10 years. This warranty provides reassurance to homeowners about the reliability of their investment and the company’s confidence in their products.
  • Customer Support: Trane has a reputation for excellent customer service, offering support through various channels and extensive resources for troubleshooting and maintenance. This commitment to customer satisfaction helps ensure that users can get assistance whenever needed.

How Do Carrier and Trane Heat Pumps Compare in Terms of Energy Efficiency?

Aspect Carrier Trane
Energy Efficiency Rating Typically rated between 14 to 20 SEER, offering good efficiency for most climates. Ranges from 14 to 22 SEER, often noted for higher efficiency in extreme conditions.
Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) SEER ratings indicate solid performance, especially in cooling mode. Generally, higher SEER ratings available, indicating superior cooling efficiency.
Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF) Commonly offers HSPF ratings of 8 to 10, making them efficient in heating. HSPF ratings can go up to 10.5, providing better performance in colder climates.
Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER) Generally offers EER ratings that support efficient performance in cooling. Typically provides higher EER ratings, especially in high-temperature conditions.
Energy-Saving Features Includes features like variable-speed compressors and smart thermostats for improved efficiency. Often equipped with advanced features like two-stage cooling and enhanced dehumidification.
Warranties Standard warranty of 10 years on parts, with options for extended coverage. Offers a 10-year limited warranty on parts, with an option for extended warranties.

What Do Customer Satisfaction Ratings Reveal About Carrier vs. Trane Heat Pumps?

Feature Carrier Trane
Customer Satisfaction Rating High ratings for reliability and performance. Excellent ratings, noted for comfort and efficiency.
Customer Satisfaction Score 4.5/5 based on recent surveys. 4.7/5 based on recent surveys.
Warranty 10-year limited warranty on parts. 10-year limited warranty, with options for extended coverage.
Energy Efficiency Offers models with up to 20 SEER rating. Known for high-efficiency models, some exceeding 22 SEER.
Noise Level Generally quieter operation in most models. Designed for low noise, with sound-dampening features.
Installation Costs Typically ranges from $3,000 to $6,000. Typically ranges from $3,500 to $7,000.
User Feedback Common praise for durability; some concerns about price. Highly rated for comfort; occasional complaints about noise.

How Do the Prices of Carrier and Trane Heat Pumps Compare?

Feature Carrier Trane
Price $3,500 – $7,500 depending on model and installation $3,800 – $8,000 based on features and efficiency
Warranty 10 years on parts; optional extended warranty 10 years on parts; additional options for labor coverage
Efficiency SEER ratings up to 20; Energy Star certified SEER ratings up to 22; known for high energy efficiency
Specific Models Infinity Series, Performance Series XV Series, XL Series
Installation Costs Additional $1,000 – $2,500 depending on complexity Additional $1,200 – $2,700 based on installation requirements
Average Lifespan 15 – 20 years 15 – 20 years
Noise Level As low as 50 dB As low as 55 dB
Customer Satisfaction High ratings, known for reliability Very high ratings, praised for performance

What Warranty Options Are Available for Carrier and Trane Heat Pumps?

The warranty options for Carrier and Trane heat pumps are designed to provide peace of mind and protect your investment over time.

  • Carrier Limited Warranty: Carrier offers a limited warranty on parts that typically lasts for 10 years when registered, ensuring coverage for essential components like compressors and heat exchangers. Additionally, Carrier provides an optional 5-year labor warranty that can be purchased, which covers labor costs for repairs, making it a comprehensive option for homeowners seeking added security.
  • Trane Limited Warranty: Trane’s limited warranty for its heat pumps also spans 10 years on parts when registered, covering critical components similarly to Carrier. Trane stands out with its optional extended warranty plans that can cover parts and labor, providing a longer-term solution for those who want to safeguard their investment against unexpected repair costs.
  • Registered vs. Unregistered Warranty: Both Carrier and Trane offer different warranty durations based on whether the product is registered within the specified time frame, usually 60 days from installation. Unregistered products often come with a shorter warranty period, which highlights the importance of timely registration to benefit from the full 10-year warranty coverage.
  • Extended Warranty Options: Both manufacturers allow homeowners to purchase extended warranties that can provide additional years of service coverage beyond the standard warranty. These options offer peace of mind, especially for those living in climates where heat pumps are crucial for heating and cooling throughout the year.

Which Heat Pump Is Best Suited for Specific Climate Conditions?

When considering the best heat pump for specific climate conditions, Carrier and Trane are two leading brands with distinct advantages.

  • Carrier Infinity Heat Pump: Known for its high efficiency and advanced technology, the Carrier Infinity series is ideal for moderate to cold climates.
  • Trane XV20i Heat Pump: This model excels in extreme weather conditions, providing reliable heating and cooling performance even in very hot or very cold temperatures.
  • Carrier Performance Heat Pump: A more budget-friendly option, the Performance series offers solid efficiency and is suitable for mild climates where extreme temperature fluctuations are less common.
  • Trane XR17 Heat Pump: This model is designed for efficiency and durability, making it a great choice for areas with varying seasonal temperatures.

The Carrier Infinity Heat Pump features variable-speed technology, allowing for precise temperature control and enhanced comfort. It is particularly beneficial in regions with fluctuating temperatures, as it can adjust its output to maintain consistent indoor conditions while optimizing energy use.

The Trane XV20i Heat Pump boasts a high SEER rating and utilizes advanced communication technology to adapt to changing weather conditions, ensuring efficient operation year-round. This model is particularly suited for climates that experience extreme seasonal shifts, providing reliable heating in winter and cooling in summer.

The Carrier Performance Heat Pump strikes a balance between cost and efficiency, making it a practical choice for homeowners in areas with mild climates. It provides decent energy efficiency without the premium features of the Infinity series, making it ideal for those looking for value.

The Trane XR17 Heat Pump is designed for performance and reliability, making it suitable for various climates. With a focus on durability and energy efficiency, it performs well in both hot summers and cool winters, making it a versatile option for homeowners.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment